Tuesday, September 6, 2005

Criticism over Katrina

I often think to myself that it would be very good if folks in the Korean government, both "progressive" and conservative, would read what is written over at Marmot's Hole. But now is a time I sincerely hope they aren't.

The usual suspects over at Marmot's Hole are falling over themselves
looking a gift horse in the mouth, busying themselves with with speculation and innuendo in order to formulate an argument over why this gift is not a gift at all. There are even hints that Korea's efforts to help are racist because the Foreign Ministry seems only concerned about ROK nationals and (according to speculation) Americans who are ethnic Koreans.

I guess to some, Korea is a country that can do no right.

Yes, the FM is putting together a task force to account for ROK nationals, and that is where some money is going, but the fifty-person rescue team is going to be saving lives and finding bodies. At at time when those same might be needed here in Korea and perhaps nearby Japan thanks to Typhoon Nabi.

Well, it turns out that Koreans are not the only ones concerned about their citizens in the Gulf region (and after all, isn't that concern something a foreign ministry is tasked with dealing with?). Australia, Hong Kong, Japan, and others in the region are
all concerned. The Australian press reports that Australian media ended up saving some of their fellow citizens.

Picking on Korea for being concerned about its citizens is just going overboard. Is this not what the U.S. government did during the Bali bombings, the tsunami, or the attack on London? I'm not saying that Bush should get prostrate in front of Roh over this, since any aid should be purely humanitarian to begin with, but what good is it if Korea is in a damned if you do and damned if you don't situation?

UPDATE (4/29/2007):
Although this article doesn't specifically mention Korea, it says that "most of the [$854 million of foreign aid] went uncollected" by the Bush Administration. The Washington Post also reports that the Bush Administration was "turning down many allies' offers of manpower, supplies and expertise worth untold millions of dollars."

What a waste at a time when so many people were suffering and dying. I sincerely hope that this news doesn't get a lot of play in the press of those countries, including Korea, from where the aid was supposed to come.

1 comment:

  1. Maybe you should change the post's title to "Thanks for Nothing."

    The mirror image is right. It's too bad that some of the knee-jerk bashers can't see they're acting the same way as the people they criticize.

    I think your recommendation to contact MOFAT and the others was a good idea. I hope a lot of people take you up on that.


Share your thoughts, but please be kind and respectful. My mom reads this blog.